Deliciously easy, homemade pecan butter with roasted pecans and a hint of sea salt and vanilla.
I always wondered why nut butters (other than PB) were so expensive and now I finally know why. It’s not because nut butter is expensive to make, it’s because shelling those darn nuts is SO time-consuming.
My colleague at work has pecan trees in his backyard and graciously donated an entire large grocery bag of pecans to my office. Although the nuts were cracked, they’ weren’t shelled and no one in the office was specifically interested in them.
So after watching the bag go mainly untouched for two days, I decided to haul it home myself.
Check out my colleague’s own blog, The Small Farm Life. I loved their goat photos and learning about rendering beeswax.
My Social Distancing Activity
The bag sat in my pantry for ~3 weeks before I finally found time to sit down and shell the pecans (thank you COVID-19) so this Saturday I plopped myself in front of the TV, turned on some trashy Bravo shows, that I absolutely needed to catch up on, (Very Cavalleri if you must know) and spent an hour and a half shelling pecans.
The result was 10 cups of beautifully fresh organic pecans. Not certified organic but the nuts didn’t have a lick of pesticides or chemicals used on them, so let’s go with organic.
Do you know how much 10 cups of pecans are worth on the nut market?
That’s ~5 pounds of nuts and according to Nuts.com, that’s about $110. Danngggggg. (Thank you Greg, if you’re reading this!)
So with my 10 cups worth of organic pecans, I decided to use half to make homemade nut butter, because I’ve never made nut butter before and wanted to try something new. And the other half I stashed away for a rainy day when I want to do some baking.
My nut butter tips:
- You can use the nut butter recipe below for any nut you have on hand
- Definitely roast your nuts before making your butter
- Just roast them for 15-20 minutes at 325F, tossing every 5 minutes
- Always let your nuts cool completely after roasting before making your butter
- Using hot nuts will result is something that is NOT nut butter
- Wait at least an hour to be safe
- A quality food processor or a high-speed blender works great
- I used my food processor and had zero issues
How I’m enjoying my nut butter:
- Straight up on a spoon!
- Spread on a graham cracker
- Morning toast with banana slices
- Mixed into oatmeal & smoothies
Looking for nut butter recipes? Try my PB scones or PB Lovers Monster Cookies.
- 5 cups shelled pecan halves
- ½-3/4 teaspoon sea salt
- ¾ teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 3-5 drops stevia, optional
- Preheat the oven to 325F
- Place your pecan halves on the baking sheet in a single layer and bake in the oven for 15-20 minutes, tossing every 5 minutes to ensure they brown evenly
- Remove nuts from the oven and allow them to cool completely before making your nut butter (do not skip this step!)
- Place the nuts in your food processor (or high-speed blender)
- Allow the food processor to run on high continuously 5-7 minutes, scraping the sides and bottom of the bowl every minute or so until a smooth, creamy nut butter forms
- Once you reach your desired consistency, add the salt, vanilla, and stevia if using. Start with the minimal amount of salt and stevia then adjust to your liking
- Enjoy immediately and store in a clean jar in the fridge for 2-3 weeks